Bo Nickal Loses to Max McEnelly, First Since 2020
Bo Nickal lost 3-2 to Max McEnelly at RAF 12, his first wrestling defeat since 2020. Here's what it means for his UFC outlook.
This article was generated with AI assistance and reviewed by our editorial team.
Bo Nickal lost a wrestling match for the first time since 2020, falling 3-2 to 2026 NCAA champion Max McEnelly at RAF 12 in Cleveland.
McEnelly, a University of Minnesota product who gave up significant size to the UFC middleweight, controlled the pace for most of the bout. He scored the match's only takedown on a go-behind that put Nickal on his stomach, then added a passivity point when Nickal couldn't generate offense during his own shot clock. Nickal answered with a passivity point of his own to make it 3-2, but ran out of real estate to work with.
In the closing stretch, Nickal abandoned any setup and just started firing at McEnelly's legs, hoping to land something before time expired. McEnelly kept sidestepping the attempts and even denied Nickal a boundary push that could have tied the match or won it on criteria. When the clock hit zero, the scoreboard read 3-2 for McEnelly.
What This Loss Means for Bo Nickal
A three-time NCAA champion at Penn State, Nickal hadn't dropped a wrestling match since he lost to teammate David Taylor at the 2020 Olympic Trials. That drought, combined with his standing as a top 15 UFC middleweight, made him the clear favorite walking into Cleveland. McEnelly didn't just hang with him, he beat him on scrambles and defense, denying Nickal any clean look at a takedown once the match tightened up.
"There's a new star in this organization," McEnelly said after the win. "I'm coming for the belt. He's a great wrestler. It finally came and it feels good to get the win. He's a good competitor. He's one of those top level guys."
Nickal does not currently have a UFC fight booked, which leaves the door open for him to seek an immediate rematch with RAF should he want to settle the score before his next octagon appearance. For now, McEnelly gets to add Nickal's name to his win column and use the moment to push his own case for a title shot in the promotion.
Betting Angle
Nickal's UFC odds shouldn't move much off a grappling exhibition loss outside the cage, but bettors who track him as a wrestling entity now have real data points against the idea that he's untouchable on the mat. A rematch, if it happens, would likely open with Nickal favored again given his size and pedigree, but sharp bettors will note McEnelly already has the blueprint: stay mobile, avoid the clinch, and make Nickal chase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who beat Bo Nickal at RAF 12?
Max McEnelly, the 2026 NCAA champion from the University of Minnesota, beat Bo Nickal 3-2 in a wrestling match at RAF 12 in Cleveland.
When was Bo Nickal's last wrestling loss before Max McEnelly?
Before losing to Max McEnelly at RAF 12, Bo Nickal's last wrestling defeat came against Penn State teammate David Taylor at the 2020 Olympic Trials.
Does Bo Nickal have a UFC fight scheduled?
Bo Nickal does not currently have his next UFC fight booked following his RAF 12 loss to Max McEnelly.
